Prison: The Unsuitable Place for Mentally-Ill Offenders
Abstract
According
to a government report, more than half prisoners in America are suffering from
mental disorders, and the situation is a call for concern because overcrowding
the prison with mentally-ill inmates will lead to negative consequences. To
prevent this situation, the justice system has to stop sentencing offenders
with mental illness to prison, because they would not get the appropriate
treatment they need to rehabilitate, besides, the result of not getting the
treatment they need might endanger their lives. Furthermore, incarceration of
mentally disordered offenders will affect the reputation of the prison and the
justice system. As solutions to let the inmates get the proper treatment they
need, and to preserve the system’s reputation, inmates with mental disorders
should be sent to mental institutions instead of prisons; and the prison should
improve the system to accommodate the mentally-ill inmates.
Prison: The Unsuitable Place for
Mentally-Ill Offenders
“Not guilty by reason of insanity” is not
an uncommon verdict in a trial, although it was used rather more frequently in
television and movies than in real life. In actual trials, the verdict is
exceedingly rare, hence many mentally unsound offenders end up in prison
instead of mental health facility, where they were truly belong. This
situation is a call for concern, because it causes congestion of inmates with
psychological problems in prisons, and it will affect the rehabilitation
process of inmates in the prison institution. Looking at the crucial points of
why mentally ill offenders should not be sentenced to prison, it is relevant to
claim that sentencing them to incarceration is not a wise, but an imprudent
decision. Offenders with psychological disorders should not be incarcerated
because imprisonment does not guarantee them feasible rehabilitation treatments;
besides, the consequences of the situation could harm the integrity and
credibility of the prison and the justice system.
Before one could be labelled as mentally
disordered, he/she has to be diagnosed by the professional
psychologist/psychiatrist who had been appointed by the law, and he/she has to
fit the definition of mental disorder. Clinically, mental illness or mental
disorder is defined as an acute psychological condition that prevents an
individual to ideally function in a society. According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5) by the American Psychiatric Association
(2013), mental disorder is:
a
syndrome characterized by clinically significant disturbance in an individual's
cognition, emotion regulation, or behavior that reflects a dysfunction in the
psychological, biological, or developmental processes underlying mental
functioning. Mental disorders are usually associated with significant distress
in social, occupational, or other important activities. An expectable or
culturally approved response to a common stressor or loss, such as the death of
a loved one, is not a mental disorder. Socially deviant behavior (e.g.,
political, religious, or sexual) and conflicts that are primarily between the
individual and society are not mental disorders unless the deviance or conflict
results from a dysfunction in the individual, as described above. (p. 20)
The
definition by the American Psychiatric
Association could be considered as a broad or general description of many
specific disorders. However, statistically, the most common disorders among
offenders in prisons are anxiety, antisocial personality disorder,
post-traumatic stress disorder, bipolar disorder, depression, and schizophrenia
(Steadman & Veysey, 1997, p. 1-5). These disorders are critical and could
deteriorate eventually if not treated and tended to, therefore an offender with
mental illness would have difficulty to live by the rule of the prison system.
Since incarceration of mentally-ill
offenders is a process that involved psychology and law, one has to be
identified in both spectrums in order to be considered as mentally unsound. What
type of criminal constitutes a mentally-ill offender in the justice system?
Seymour L. Halleck (1987) identifies mentally disordered offenders on the basis
of, first, the evidence that they have committed a crime must be sufficient to
lead to their arrest and arraignment; second, an agency of the criminal justice
system must suspect that they have a mental disorder of such proportion as to
question the fairness or utility of subjecting them to the usual criminal
justice process (p. 1). By the details given by Halleck, and the definition of
mental disorder in clinical term, it is clear that a person could not merely be
labelled as a mentally-ill offender without a proper process. However, problem
will arise when the judge and the jury refuse to accept an offender as mentally
unsound, even after he/she has been proven psychologically disordered by the
process indicated.
When the jury and the judge ignore the fact
that the offender is mentally unstable and in need of psychological treatments,
the judge would sentence him/her to prison, thus affects the offender and the
prison system detrimentally. One of the negative effects of sentencing the
mentally disordered to prison is, it will overcrowd the prison with mentally
unsound inmates, and this situation will interrupt the process of
rehabilitation of the inmates and other mentally sound prisoners. According to
Bureau of Justice statistics report, more than half of prisons and jail inmates
had a mental health problem, and this includes inmates in State prisons, Federal
prisons, and local jails (James & Glaze, 2006, p. 1). With this official
report from the Bureau of Justice, it is proven that most offenders with mental
disorders were sentenced to prison, and obliged to live by the rule of the
prison system, even though they might not understand the system itself and its
affair, thus the rehabilitation process might not be achieved, and they could
get back into crime once released. Furthermore, as the inmates are mentally
unstable, their deranged behaviors would disturb the rehabilitation process of
other inmates who are mentally sound.
Having mentally-ill offenders in
prison could risk the safety of the staffs, other inmates and the mentally
disordered inmates themselves. Some people who are suffering from mental disorders
could be aggressive, delusional and/or psychotic, therefore they could behave
aggressively towards others and the staffs. From a documentary titled The New Asylum, directed and produced by
Miri Novasky and Karen O’Connor (2005), a mentally disordered inmate named Carl
McEachron, who was sentenced to prison for burglary, and later for violation of
his parole, was kept under medium security, to maximum security, and eventually
to the super maximum security due to his acute behavior. McEachron was reported
to be aggressive towards the staffs and other inmates. The documentary verifies
that prison is not a suitable place to rehabilitate mentally-ill offenders, and
in every prison, there are hundreds who suffer the same difficulty as
McEachron. Therefore, having mentally disordered inmates in prison is a risky
situation, because they could attack others unpredictably.
On the other hand, mentally disordered
inmates also might be dangerous to themselves, as they could be suicidal during
the incarceration, especially for those who suffer chronic depression, bipolar
disorders, and manic depressive. According to H. Hafner and W. Boker about
suicide cases in prison (1982), “The proportion of patients with depressive
psychosis or manic depressive illnesses whose cause of death was suicide, lies
between about 9 to 50 percent [from the total research sample]. For
schizophrenia, the corresponding figures are between about 6 to 10 percent” (p.
283). The report shows that mentally disordered inmates are more dangerous to
themselves than to others, therefore, their incarceration could increase the
percentage of suicides in prison, which would harm the credibility of the
justice and prison system.
Being in prison, the mentally ill
offenders were denied the proper and much needed help they required, and the
consequences of not getting a proper or the right treatment might endanger
their life. In 2006, Timothy Souders, a 21 year-old mentally disordered inmate,
had died in prison while serving his three to five year sentence for
shoplifting. Prior to his death, Souders was chained down to the floor for 17
hours due to his acute behavior before finally collapsed and pronounced dead,
and the cause of death was dehydration. From the interview with his mother,
Souders was described as difficult, suicidal, and sometimes delusional since he
was a teenager due to his anxiety disorders and manic depression. He was also
believed to be needed an urgent psychiatric care rather than being sentenced to
prison (Pelly & Granatstein, 2007). The awful treatment received by Souders
was recorded through the prison camera and was revealed in a segment of a
documentary titled 60 Minutes.
Souders’ case depicts the negligence of the prison system towards mentally ill
inmates, and it costs a life of a person, and it also affects the integrity of
the system. The case had proven that mentally ill offenders are not suited to
be incarcerated, because they need a proper treatment in order for them to
rehabilitate and reform well.
Incarceration of the mentally-ill inmates
will not only harm the inmates, but also the prison system. Cases such as Souders
will affects the integrity of the system as a rehabilitation institution. According
to BBC News, eighty mentally ill US
prisoners have died since 2003 as a result of abuse or neglect (Anderson,
2014). The number reported by the news is significant, because it shows that
even with many cases of death, the system and/or the state has not done much to
prevent or improve the situation, and this will harm the system’s reputation.
Furthermore, Anderson (2014) reports that “Joshua Messier, 23, of Boston, who
had schizophrenia, died in 2009 after four guards tried to strap him down to a
restraint bed, doubling him over and compressing his chest”. With this report,
it clearly shows that the treatment given to the mentally-ill inmates in prison
is not the right treatment, and the situation happens due to lack of training;
and the information provided to the guards on how to treat and tend to mentally-ill
inmates might be insufficient. Therefore, mentally disordered offenders should
be treated at the appropriate place, where they could get proper treatments by qualified
individuals, and not be incarcerated in order to preserve the integrity of the
system.
The issue of mentally-ill offenders
and prison is a critical issue, and actions need to be taken promptly, because
these inmates will get back into the society and if they are not rehabilitated,
they might not be able to function well in the community and they might get
back to crime. To resolve the issue, there are two possible solutions, and one
of the solutions is to place the mentally-ill offenders in mental institutions
where they could get proper treatments by the professionals. In mental
institutions, the inmates would be treated with counseling, suitable medication
and appropriate treatment according to their diagnosis. Additionally, the
environment in mental institutions is calmer and better than prison, thus will
enforce the psychological treatment. Furthermore, the inmates will be treated
with other mentally disordered individuals/inmates, therefore the process will
not be difficult and hard, because the staffs will treat the inmates according
to their mental stability, while in prison the guards might not be able to
distinguish mentally unsound inmates with the normal inmates. Mental
institution is a solution to let the mentally-ill offenders to get the proper
treatment they require in order to fully rehabilitate, and with the right
treatment, they might not get back to crimes once released.
Another solution could be considered
is an improvisation of the mental health facility in prison. If institutionalized
prisoners could involve a high budget, and seems difficult to effectuate, then
the prison should improve their system in accommodating mentally-ill offenders.
Presently, the prison system segregates the mentally disordered who behaved aggressively,
but segregation would only deteriorate their condition (Byron, 2014).
Professionals and qualified individuals should be placed in the prison to help
and supervise the mentally disordered properly. Additionally, the inmates also
should be getting counseling sessions and appropriate psychiatric evaluations
to determine their progress in rehabilitation. By restoring and improvising the
mental health facility in prison, the unpleasant circumstances, such as suicide
and death could be prevented, and by doing so, the integrity and credibility of
the prison system would be preserved.
Prison should be a place for
offenders not only to get punishment, but to reintegrate themselves to be a
better person and fit well in the society. However, mentally disordered
offenders should get treated psychologically in order for them to perfectly
understand the process of rehabilitation. Incarceration is not the suitable
treatment for them because it will deteriorate their condition and might get
them into crime again once they are released from prison. Additionally,
maltreatment might endanger their lives and could harm the credibility of the
justice and prison system. Psychological treatment for the mentally ill person
is a need to survive, therefore before one could question in term of
rehabilitation, the basic human need for survival for these inmates should be
assured first.
References
American
Psychiatric Association (2013). Diagnostic
and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders
(5th ed.). Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Publishing.
Anderson,
H. (2014). Eighty mentally ill US prisoners have died since 2003. BBC News.
Retrieved from http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-28127662
Byron,
R. (2014). Criminals Need Mental Health Care. Scientific American Mind, 25 (2).
care/
Hafner,
H. & Boker, W. (1982). Crimes of Violence
by Mentally Abnormal Offenders: a
psychiatric
and epidemiological study in the federal German Republic
(H. Marshall, Trans.). New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Halleck,
S. L. (1987). The Mentally Disordered
Offender. Washington, D.C: National Institute of
Mental Health.
James,
D. J. & Glaze, L. E. (2006). Mental Health Problems of Prison and Jail
Inmates. Bureau
of
Justice Statistics Special Report. Retrieved from U.S.
Department of Justice:
http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/mhppji.pdf
Novasky,
M & O’Connor, K. (Writers & Directors). (2005). The New Asylum
[Documentary
series
episode]. In M. Novasky & K. O’Connor (Producer), Frontline. Arlington, VA: PBS, Public Broadcasting Service
Pelly,
S. (2007, July 22). The Death of Timothy Souders. [Television Broadcast]. In
Granatstein,
S. (Producer), 60 Minutes. New York, NY: CBS Broadcasting
Steadman,
H. J. & Veysey, B. M. (1997). Providing Service for Jail Inmates With
Mental
Disorders. National Institute of Justice, Research in Brief. Retrieved from
U.S.
Department of Justice:
https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles/162207.pdf
