Wednesday, May 20, 2015

Research Paper

Prison: The Unsuitable Place for Mentally-Ill Offenders


Abstract
According to a government report, more than half prisoners in America are suffering from mental disorders, and the situation is a call for concern because overcrowding the prison with mentally-ill inmates will lead to negative consequences. To prevent this situation, the justice system has to stop sentencing offenders with mental illness to prison, because they would not get the appropriate treatment they need to rehabilitate, besides, the result of not getting the treatment they need might endanger their lives. Furthermore, incarceration of mentally disordered offenders will affect the reputation of the prison and the justice system. As solutions to let the inmates get the proper treatment they need, and to preserve the system’s reputation, inmates with mental disorders should be sent to mental institutions instead of prisons; and the prison should improve the system to accommodate the mentally-ill inmates. 

  

Prison: The Unsuitable Place for Mentally-Ill Offenders
“Not guilty by reason of insanity” is not an uncommon verdict in a trial, although it was used rather more frequently in television and movies than in real life. In actual trials, the verdict is exceedingly rare, hence many mentally unsound offenders end up in prison instead of mental health facility, where they were truly belong. This situation is a call for concern, because it causes congestion of inmates with psychological problems in prisons, and it will affect the rehabilitation process of inmates in the prison institution. Looking at the crucial points of why mentally ill offenders should not be sentenced to prison, it is relevant to claim that sentencing them to incarceration is not a wise, but an imprudent decision. Offenders with psychological disorders should not be incarcerated because imprisonment does not guarantee them feasible rehabilitation treatments; besides, the consequences of the situation could harm the integrity and credibility of the prison and the justice system.
Before one could be labelled as mentally disordered, he/she has to be diagnosed by the professional psychologist/psychiatrist who had been appointed by the law, and he/she has to fit the definition of mental disorder. Clinically, mental illness or mental disorder is defined as an acute psychological condition that prevents an individual to ideally function in a society. According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5) by the American Psychiatric Association (2013), mental disorder is:
a syndrome characterized by clinically significant disturbance in an individual's cognition, emotion regulation, or behavior that reflects a dysfunction in the psychological, biological, or developmental processes underlying mental functioning. Mental disorders are usually associated with significant distress in social, occupational, or other important activities. An expectable or culturally approved response to a common stressor or loss, such as the death of a loved one, is not a mental disorder. Socially deviant behavior (e.g., political, religious, or sexual) and conflicts that are primarily between the individual and society are not mental disorders unless the deviance or conflict results from a dysfunction in the individual, as described above. (p. 20)
The definition by the American Psychiatric Association could be considered as a broad or general description of many specific disorders. However, statistically, the most common disorders among offenders in prisons are anxiety, antisocial personality disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder, bipolar disorder, depression, and schizophrenia (Steadman & Veysey, 1997, p. 1-5). These disorders are critical and could deteriorate eventually if not treated and tended to, therefore an offender with mental illness would have difficulty to live by the rule of the prison system.
            Since incarceration of mentally-ill offenders is a process that involved psychology and law, one has to be identified in both spectrums in order to be considered as mentally unsound. What type of criminal constitutes a mentally-ill offender in the justice system? Seymour L. Halleck (1987) identifies mentally disordered offenders on the basis of, first, the evidence that they have committed a crime must be sufficient to lead to their arrest and arraignment; second, an agency of the criminal justice system must suspect that they have a mental disorder of such proportion as to question the fairness or utility of subjecting them to the usual criminal justice process (p. 1). By the details given by Halleck, and the definition of mental disorder in clinical term, it is clear that a person could not merely be labelled as a mentally-ill offender without a proper process. However, problem will arise when the judge and the jury refuse to accept an offender as mentally unsound, even after he/she has been proven psychologically disordered by the process indicated.
 When the jury and the judge ignore the fact that the offender is mentally unstable and in need of psychological treatments, the judge would sentence him/her to prison, thus affects the offender and the prison system detrimentally. One of the negative effects of sentencing the mentally disordered to prison is, it will overcrowd the prison with mentally unsound inmates, and this situation will interrupt the process of rehabilitation of the inmates and other mentally sound prisoners. According to Bureau of Justice statistics report, more than half of prisons and jail inmates had a mental health problem, and this includes inmates in State prisons, Federal prisons, and local jails (James & Glaze, 2006, p. 1). With this official report from the Bureau of Justice, it is proven that most offenders with mental disorders were sentenced to prison, and obliged to live by the rule of the prison system, even though they might not understand the system itself and its affair, thus the rehabilitation process might not be achieved, and they could get back into crime once released. Furthermore, as the inmates are mentally unstable, their deranged behaviors would disturb the rehabilitation process of other inmates who are mentally sound.
            Having mentally-ill offenders in prison could risk the safety of the staffs, other inmates and the mentally disordered inmates themselves. Some people who are suffering from mental disorders could be aggressive, delusional and/or psychotic, therefore they could behave aggressively towards others and the staffs. From a documentary titled The New Asylum, directed and produced by Miri Novasky and Karen O’Connor (2005), a mentally disordered inmate named Carl McEachron, who was sentenced to prison for burglary, and later for violation of his parole, was kept under medium security, to maximum security, and eventually to the super maximum security due to his acute behavior. McEachron was reported to be aggressive towards the staffs and other inmates. The documentary verifies that prison is not a suitable place to rehabilitate mentally-ill offenders, and in every prison, there are hundreds who suffer the same difficulty as McEachron. Therefore, having mentally disordered inmates in prison is a risky situation, because they could attack others unpredictably.   
On the other hand, mentally disordered inmates also might be dangerous to themselves, as they could be suicidal during the incarceration, especially for those who suffer chronic depression, bipolar disorders, and manic depressive. According to H. Hafner and W. Boker about suicide cases in prison (1982), “The proportion of patients with depressive psychosis or manic depressive illnesses whose cause of death was suicide, lies between about 9 to 50 percent [from the total research sample]. For schizophrenia, the corresponding figures are between about 6 to 10 percent” (p. 283). The report shows that mentally disordered inmates are more dangerous to themselves than to others, therefore, their incarceration could increase the percentage of suicides in prison, which would harm the credibility of the justice and prison system.
            Being in prison, the mentally ill offenders were denied the proper and much needed help they required, and the consequences of not getting a proper or the right treatment might endanger their life. In 2006, Timothy Souders, a 21 year-old mentally disordered inmate, had died in prison while serving his three to five year sentence for shoplifting. Prior to his death, Souders was chained down to the floor for 17 hours due to his acute behavior before finally collapsed and pronounced dead, and the cause of death was dehydration. From the interview with his mother, Souders was described as difficult, suicidal, and sometimes delusional since he was a teenager due to his anxiety disorders and manic depression. He was also believed to be needed an urgent psychiatric care rather than being sentenced to prison (Pelly & Granatstein, 2007). The awful treatment received by Souders was recorded through the prison camera and was revealed in a segment of a documentary titled 60 Minutes. Souders’ case depicts the negligence of the prison system towards mentally ill inmates, and it costs a life of a person, and it also affects the integrity of the system. The case had proven that mentally ill offenders are not suited to be incarcerated, because they need a proper treatment in order for them to rehabilitate and reform well.
            Incarceration of the mentally-ill inmates will not only harm the inmates, but also the prison system. Cases such as Souders will affects the integrity of the system as a rehabilitation institution. According to BBC News, eighty mentally ill US prisoners have died since 2003 as a result of abuse or neglect (Anderson, 2014). The number reported by the news is significant, because it shows that even with many cases of death, the system and/or the state has not done much to prevent or improve the situation, and this will harm the system’s reputation. Furthermore, Anderson (2014) reports that “Joshua Messier, 23, of Boston, who had schizophrenia, died in 2009 after four guards tried to strap him down to a restraint bed, doubling him over and compressing his chest”. With this report, it clearly shows that the treatment given to the mentally-ill inmates in prison is not the right treatment, and the situation happens due to lack of training; and the information provided to the guards on how to treat and tend to mentally-ill inmates might be insufficient. Therefore, mentally disordered offenders should be treated at the appropriate place, where they could get proper treatments by qualified individuals, and not be incarcerated in order to preserve the integrity of the system.
            The issue of mentally-ill offenders and prison is a critical issue, and actions need to be taken promptly, because these inmates will get back into the society and if they are not rehabilitated, they might not be able to function well in the community and they might get back to crime. To resolve the issue, there are two possible solutions, and one of the solutions is to place the mentally-ill offenders in mental institutions where they could get proper treatments by the professionals. In mental institutions, the inmates would be treated with counseling, suitable medication and appropriate treatment according to their diagnosis. Additionally, the environment in mental institutions is calmer and better than prison, thus will enforce the psychological treatment. Furthermore, the inmates will be treated with other mentally disordered individuals/inmates, therefore the process will not be difficult and hard, because the staffs will treat the inmates according to their mental stability, while in prison the guards might not be able to distinguish mentally unsound inmates with the normal inmates. Mental institution is a solution to let the mentally-ill offenders to get the proper treatment they require in order to fully rehabilitate, and with the right treatment, they might not get back to crimes once released.
            Another solution could be considered is an improvisation of the mental health facility in prison. If institutionalized prisoners could involve a high budget, and seems difficult to effectuate, then the prison should improve their system in accommodating mentally-ill offenders. Presently, the prison system segregates the mentally disordered who behaved aggressively, but segregation would only deteriorate their condition (Byron, 2014). Professionals and qualified individuals should be placed in the prison to help and supervise the mentally disordered properly. Additionally, the inmates also should be getting counseling sessions and appropriate psychiatric evaluations to determine their progress in rehabilitation. By restoring and improvising the mental health facility in prison, the unpleasant circumstances, such as suicide and death could be prevented, and by doing so, the integrity and credibility of the prison system would be preserved.
            Prison should be a place for offenders not only to get punishment, but to reintegrate themselves to be a better person and fit well in the society. However, mentally disordered offenders should get treated psychologically in order for them to perfectly understand the process of rehabilitation. Incarceration is not the suitable treatment for them because it will deteriorate their condition and might get them into crime again once they are released from prison. Additionally, maltreatment might endanger their lives and could harm the credibility of the justice and prison system. Psychological treatment for the mentally ill person is a need to survive, therefore before one could question in term of rehabilitation, the basic human need for survival for these inmates should be assured first.        




References
American Psychiatric Association (2013). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders (5th ed.). Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Publishing.
Anderson, H. (2014). Eighty mentally ill US prisoners have died since 2003. BBC News.
Retrieved from http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-28127662
Byron, R. (2014). Criminals Need Mental Health Care. Scientific American Mind, 25 (2).
care/
Hafner, H. & Boker, W. (1982). Crimes of Violence by Mentally Abnormal Offenders: a
psychiatric and epidemiological study in the federal German Republic (H. Marshall, Trans.). New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Halleck, S. L. (1987). The Mentally Disordered Offender. Washington, D.C: National Institute of
Mental Health.
James, D. J. & Glaze, L. E. (2006). Mental Health Problems of Prison and Jail Inmates. Bureau 
of Justice Statistics Special Report. Retrieved from U.S. Department of Justice:
http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/mhppji.pdf  
Novasky, M & O’Connor, K. (Writers & Directors). (2005). The New Asylum [Documentary
series episode]. In M. Novasky & K. O’Connor (Producer), Frontline. Arlington, VA: PBS, Public Broadcasting Service
Pelly, S. (2007, July 22). The Death of Timothy Souders. [Television Broadcast]. In Granatstein,
S. (Producer), 60 Minutes. New York, NY: CBS Broadcasting
Steadman, H. J. & Veysey, B. M. (1997). Providing Service for Jail Inmates With Mental
Disorders. National Institute of Justice, Research in Brief. Retrieved from U.S.
Department of Justice:  https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles/162207.pdf

   

Sunday, May 17, 2015

Movie Review

Laskar Pelangi/The Rainbow Troops:
Simple, yet Highly Inspirational




"Just dance and keep on laughing, though the world does not compare to the paradise" Laskar Pelangi

          Laskar Pelangi or The Rainbow Troops is an Indonesian, true-story movie adapted from a novel by Andrea Hirata with the same title. Set in Belitung, a rural village in Indonesia, the story is about ten boys who had to struggle to attain education by attending an underprivileged school in a village where most of the children do not go to school, but have to work as coolies to help with the financial difficulties of their families. Bearing the importance of education, and the strong will to achieve a dream, the movie carries strong values and important messages. Although competing with productions of movies with high technology from the local and international market, The Rainbow Troops succeeds to stand without a big budget and excessive special effects by relying solely on compelling issues, a moving storyline, powerful dialogues, and convincing performance by the actors. The Rainbow Troops is an inspiring movie because it portrays the significance of education, and shows that the real value of education lies in what one learns, not where he/she attains the knowledge.
A movie should not only be a medium to convey a story, but also a mean to inspire, and that is what The Rainbow Troop is. The movie starts with a boy named Ikal on his first day of school at a school called Muhammadiyah. The school is an underprivileged new school that needs to have at least ten students in order to operate. As the school succeeds to have ten students, who are mostly from an underprivileged family, the education processes start with two teachers and a headmaster under an unimpressive condition. While students in well-recognized schools solve mathematics problems with a calculator, the students in Muhammadiyah use sticks to count and solve mathematics, but nevertheless, they learn and gain knowledge just as well. The poor condition endured by the students does not break their spirit to be a better person with an education. Besides Ikal, the story focuses on a bright student named Lintang, and a creative, artistic student called Mahar. The highlight of the story comes when Ikal, Lintang and Mahar joined an educational competition and won against a privileged school. However, at the end of the story, the plot turns to emotionally heartbreaking when the brilliant Lintang could not continue his education because he has to work and support his younger brothers, as his father died. Ikal continues his education, and succeeds in achieving his dream to study in Paris. By ending the story with Ikal’s success, the movie leaves the audience with a hope that even underprivileged students who comes from a poor family could attain victory and success, and that makes the movie appealing and inspiring.
The Rainbow Troops is a movie that could leave a strong impression and a powerful inspiration to the audience. The influential dialogues conversed by the characters make the movie even more moving, for example, in one of the scenes, the principal of Muhammadiyah said “In this school, moral lessons are not merely there just to complete the curriculum. The students’ intelligence is not just measured by grades and numbers, but also their hearts”. This dialogue by the principal really describes the movie and its high value. The Rainbow Troops is a worth-watching movie that is significant, because it enlightens the audience with the importance of education. Additionally, it also reflects one’s advantage to have the privilege to study in a fine condition compared to those who have to struggle to achieve their dream. Therefore, education should never be taken for granted, because it is one of the highest values one could attain.      



The Rainbow Troops Trailer


Monday, May 11, 2015

Journal Entry 10

Reflection on Writing

Writing is an essential skill in life, and as a student, I believe it is important for me to master this skill and keep trying my best to be a better writer every time I write. Having the experience to write various types of writing in this class, I was able to achieve my goal to improve my writing skill, and attained the most valuable lesson, which was being enlightened by many life experience, story, and narrative from various prominent figures through the readings and writings assigned.  
            Writing needs skills, and to attain the skills, one has to learn and practice. Writing for this course had taught me plenty in term of skill, process and knowledge. Through the writings and in-class lessons, I attained the knowledge of various genres of writing, essay structure, writing components, and the three important elements in writing: ethos, logos and pathos. Additionally, I also learnt about global and local structure/revision in writing and viewing an essay, and this guide is very important, because it makes me write my ideas freely and thoroughly, without being overly concerned about the local part such as grammar and sentence at the earlier stage of writing. Moreover, I now understand how important a thesis statement is in an essay. Without a thesis statement, one’s writing might be ambiguous, and unclear, thus confusing the readers.
            In terms of practice, the writings assigned almost every week for this course had provided me with many chances to exercise my writing skills. In every writing, my goal is to write better, and therefore every time I write, I attempt to apply every lesson I learnt. However, I do realize that I need to work better on my skills, and keep improving my writing, especially in writing a scholarly paper. As I plan to continue my study to the highest degree, I believe I need to keep practicing to achieve the standard required for a graduate student. Writing for this course had helped me to improve extensively. I believe through the writings, my essay had been better in term of structure and composition, and my ideas are more relevant and significant. Learning and practicing are two important keys in attaining writing skills, and through this course, I believe I had grasped the keys.              
Writing should not be just a platform to voice out one’s opinion, but it is also should be a process to open up one’s mind and embrace wisdom. This course had frequently assigned reflection, reaction, and/or analytical writing, and to write the essay, students need to read various significant, interesting articles. Some articles narrate the authors’ experience and/or opinion, some provide important information, while some just fictional stories, but all of the articles are enlightening and related to the course. The readings made me reflect on my own life and experience, and had me think critically. For example, the article by Jane Maher titled Raw Material made me feel lucky to have the advantage of freedom and education, compared to Maher’s students in prison. Additionally, Martin Luther King, Jr’s letter titled Letter from Birmingham Jail let me feel the harsh life of the Black people in that era, and from all of the reading materials assigned in this class, this letter by King had affected me the most through the beautiful words and delightful ideas.
Writing is a beautiful skill one should master and improve every time, and every writer should get better with every single writing he/she compose. For me, writing for this course had benefited me greatly as I had learned a lot about writing, and was able to practice my writing skills. Additionally, this course had not only taught me to be a better writer, but also a better person, with a better idea and perspective, and for me, that makes this course a truly meaningful course.   

Sunday, May 10, 2015

Journal Entry 9

Reaction to Aging on a Cellular Level 

In the modern world, particularly nowadays, aging is a nightmare for most people in the contemporary society, and therefore various cosmetic product were used to prevent and/or reverse the process of aging. Alina Thomas (2015) in her research paper disapproves the widely belief of anti-aging process. She argues that aging consist of stages of natural occurring cycle that science could only assist to achieve in a healthy way, but the complete reversal of the process is unattainable (p.2). Thomas has stated a legit thesis, but looking at the current situation in the society, the mindset might be hard to change. Additionally, the media, who always has a huge impact on the society, has played an important role in rooting the idea of beauty, which reject the concept of aging and its process. People will continue to prevent aging or reverse the process in the name of beauty if awareness of the reality of it would not be forced on the society, and those who are aware, would strive for healthy process of aging instead.
Aging is just part of living. People should embrace the process, and aim to live a healthy life because beauty reflects ones’ lifestyle and health. Therefore, it is important to educate people on what beauty really is, and how healthy lifestyle could help the process of aging in a better way than consuming cosmetic products. Only with awareness and education could the society change their perspectives. Being old should not be a terrifying experience, because no matter what one does, his/her age would increase, and his/her body would not be as the same as when he/she was younger. Therefore in creating awareness to the society, the most important message to be delivered is, accept oneself, and live every stage of live fully and healthily, because only by then, beauty will naturally emerge.        


Reference
Thomas, A. (2015). Aging on a Cellular Level: The Unreversed Biological Processes Behind
Aging. 


Journal Entry 8

Reaction to Out of the Shadows

In Out of the Shadows, the author discussed in details the topic of slavery and human trafficking, and why people should be concerned with the issue. In the article, the author describes a horrific experience of a girl named Maria from a book titled The Slave Next Door, and how she was dragged into the world of slavery. Maria was not the only victim in this crucial, disturbing issue, unfortunately, thousands of Marias went through the same torturing experience. Slavery should be taken seriously because it affects many important aspects in a nation, such as economy, population, and society, and most importantly, it violates humanity. In addressing the solution of the critical issue of slavery, awareness is the first and the most important step.
            Slavery should be tackled, but people should not rely on the government alone because it would not be sufficient. The most important thing in solving any issue is awareness, and that should be the starting point on this issue too. Although slavery or human trafficking is not a new issue, many do not aware how crucial it is, therefore public should be aware of the significance of this issue for a country, and to humanity. When people are enlightened about this issue to the core, the realization of how important for every person in a society to play a part in resolving this matter would materialize. Every life is important and matter, therefore it is vital for this issue to be resolved as soon as possible. 

Thursday, May 7, 2015

Journal Entry 7

Reflection on The Birthmark

The Birthmark, by Nathaniel Hawthorne is a moving fiction which explores the meaning of true love, obsession and perfection. The story revolves around two main characters, Aylmer and Georgiana. Aylmer is a scientist who marries Georgiana, a beautiful woman with a birthmark on her cheek. After they were married, Aylmer could not look pass the birthmark which he found hideous and distracting, although he did not seem to mind the mark before they were married. He loves Georgiana, but the obsession to erase the birthmark on her cheek seems to get stronger than the love he has for her, and as Georgiana loves her husband so much, she agreed to let him removes the mark. After Aylmer removed the mark, Georgiana becomes weaker day by day, and at the end, she died. Through the story, it shows that one should love another unconditionally, and accept the other person’s imperfection thoroughly, because no one is perfect in this life.
Love is a pure emotion that should come with sincerity and devotion. In the story, Aylmer fails to fulfill the love he has for his wife by being obsess with science, and tries to make her perfect according to his opinion on beauty. The mark on her check should make Georgiana more beautiful in Aylmer’s eyes as he has supposedly be in love with her and accept her sincerely, but his repulsion and obsession suggests that he might not love his wife with all his heart. With his narcissistic personality, perhaps Aylmer married Georgiana to prove that he is the best, and could win her over other men who were waiting to ask her hand in marriage, and to prove himself further, he resorts to make her perfect after they were married. If Aylmer did marry his wife to prove himself, then Aylmer was never truly in love with Georgiana, because if he had, he would always be able to look beyond her imperfection, especially when it is something that is related to look. As a human, imperfection is actually an essential to be a perfect person, therefore one should love the other person’s flaw, because it is part of him/her that makes him/her a whole person. To quote a notable author and philosopher, Sam Keen (1997), on love and acceptance, “We come to love not by finding a perfect person, but by learning to see an imperfect person perfectly” (Cited from BrainyQuote, 2015). Through the wise quote, it depicts how important it is to accept a person with his/her imperfection, and as love grows, one should tend to learn the imperfection thoroughly and accept it, because love is acceptance and tolerance.



Read the tale here: 
The Birthmark



Reference
BrainyQuote. (2015). Sam Keen Quotes. BrainyQuote. Retrieved from
http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/s/samkeen171241.html


Research Outline

Mental Institution or Prison:
The Better Place for Mentally Ill Offenders

Not every offender with mental illness ended up in mental institute. Most of the offenders were sentenced to prison and had to live with other inmates even though their mental stability is not in a good stage. The questions to draw from this research are, whether sentencing offenders with mental disorders to live in prison is correct and wise? ; Which better fit offender with mental illness, prison or mental institution? The hypothesis or tentative thesis statement is, offenders who were proved to have psychological disorders should be placed in a mental health care facility instead of a prison, because they will get a better chance to recover and transform or rehabilitate as their mental condition would not make them suitable for incarceration without professional help and/or supervision.
The justice and prison system should worry about current prison situation where most prisons were congested with inmates with mental disorders. According to Bureau of Justice statistics report, more than half of all prison and jail inmates had a mental health problem in State, federal and local jails (James & Glaze, 2006, p. 1). With this finding, it shows that probably most offenders with mental health issue were sentenced to prison, therefore make the prison crowded, and this circumstances should be taking seriously and be concerned with.
Inmates with mental illness would not fit in prison, as they need professional help and supervision, and it will endanger their life to live in prison. One of the examples is Timothy Souders and his death in prison due to the harsh treatment he received in prison for his aggressive behavior resulted from mental disorders.  Souders was sentenced to prison for shoplifting, and had died in prison while serving his three to five year. Prior to his death, Souders was chained down on the floor for 17 hours due to his acute behavior before finally collapsed and pronounced dead, and the cause of death was dehydration. Since adolescence, Souders was described as difficult, suicidal, and sometimes delusional due to his anxiety disorders and manic depression. He was also believed to be needed an urgent psychiatric care rather than being sentenced to prison (Pelly, 2007). This case study clearly depicts the importance of an offender with mental disorders to be institutionalized in mental health facility rather than prison, because it may endanger his/her life and it will bring a bad reputation to the justice and prison system. 
The concerned situation could be reversed and corrected. According to Mark Moran (2004), The Treatment Advocacy Center offers several recommendations for how states can reverse the situation, and they are:
Assisted outpatient treatment that requires selected seriously mentally ill people to take medication under court order as a condition for living in the community; mental health courts that give offenders a choice between agreeing and adhering to a treatment plan or going to jail; unannounced state surveys by the Department of Justice or Institute of Medicine in each state, [it could] enumerate the number of seriously mentally ill people in jails and prisons and tie federal mental health block grant funding to the results by state; repeal of the Medicaid Institute for Mental Diseases (IMD) Exclusion, [it] would provide for greater federal funding of treatment in the community, the IMD exclusion prohibits federal Medicaid matching funds from going to inpatient facilities with more than 16 beds whose patient roster is more than 51 percent people with severe mental illness; reforming treatment laws could make mental health treatment in the community based on need rather than dangerousness (para. 14).
The suggestions are important, and should be taken into consideration by the justice system because they are relevant and significant. The suggestions also would make a better condition for offenders with mental illness. 
            Mental institution for offenders with mental disorders might reduce recidivism than those who were imprisoned. Robert Byron (2014) in his report states that “Given the mental state of [the] former inmates—people who were not found insane during their trials—patients found not guilty by reason of insanity might seem to be especially disordered, and so they can be. Yet after their release, having been confined in mental hospitals, not prisons, not only are they less likely to reoffend than disordered inmates, but they are even less recidivist than offenders without a recognized mental illness.” (para. 11). From this statement by Byron, who had studied the recidivism rates for offenders with mental health issue, it proves that letting criminals to get mental help they need is beneficial as it might rehabilitate them better than prison, and that should be the purpose of punishment, to transform an offender to be a better person.  





References
Byron, R. (2014). Criminals Need Mental Health Care. Scientific American Mind, 25 (2).
James, D. J. & Glaze, L. E. (2006). Mental Health Problems of Prison and Jail Inmates. Bureau 
of Justice Statistics Special Report. Retrieved from U.S. Department of Justice:
http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/mhppji.pdf  
Moran, M. (2014). Jail More Likely Than Hospital for Severely Mentally Ill. Psychiatric News,
Pelly, S. (2007, July 22). The Death of Timothy Souders. [Television Broadcast]. In Granatstein,
S. (Producer), 60 Minutes. New York, NY: CBS Broadcasting


Take-Home Test

A Better Person

Jane Maher’s article titled Raw Material is truly an eye-opener on how important education is, and it is equally important to have interest in it. The article made me reflect back on my own experience of being a prison counselor in my country, Malaysia. During my first Bachelor Degree study in Malaysia, I had the most interesting experience doing my internship as a counselor for woman inmates in Women’s Prison of Penjara Kajang, Malaysia. Even though it was for only three months, the experience was irreplaceable. Being a counselor, and listen to the inmates’ thoughts and histories, I realized how privilege I am to have the opportunity to pursue my dream to further my study, and to have the interest to continue my education, which most of the inmates did not have. Education is important because it will lead to wisdom and maturity, and it does not matter where one learns, but what he/she learns. 
            This article is about the author’s experience being a teacher for women inmates, and how she empathized with her students, and felt responsible to thoroughly educate them for their better future. Through writing assignments assigned to her students, Maher was able to see their personality, characteristics, and even their past. Some stories she read scared and alarmed her, while some inspired her. Furthermore, Maher was able to see and compare her students in prison and regular students who might take education for granted because they could get it easily. For her students in prison, even small activities related to education - which to regular students might be boring and tedious - could excite them, and they would give their full attention to the activities. Maher realized how important education was to her students, although they lived in a world separated from others. She treasured the experience dearly and learned a lot from her students.
            Education is the most powerful tool to reach maturity. With education, comes knowledge, and with knowledge, one could think and act maturely even in the least pleasant circumstance or place such as prison. Furthermore, maturity and sensibility are the aspects that distinguish those with education and those without. Based on her experience, Maher (2011) states that “I know the women fight from time to time, and I have heard of women being injured and/or receiving severe punishments for these fights, but such incidents are truly rare in the college program. It’s no different than on the outside – the inmates in the college program tend to be more mature, more able to control their impulses emotion” (p. 18). Maher’s experience shows that even for inmates, those with education behave sensibly than those who are less fortunate not to have education, and it reflects how significant knowledge is in one’s life.
            Wisdom is the quality that compliment maturity at best, therefore being a sensible and mature person, one also has to think wisely, and to achieve this state, education is very much needed. With knowledge, a person could wisely think the best path for his/her future, and might be able to resist negative temptation base on a better judgement and sense. For inmates, this sense is an important essential, because with this sense, they would want a better life once they are free from prison, and they would refuse to get back into crime. A study on the impact of college on prisoners conducted by a professor from City University of New York, Michele Fine, shows that recidivism rates drop in direct proportion to the number of years of post-secondary education (Maher, 2011, p. 28). From this study, it clearly proves that a person, even an inmate, would think better with education, and thus signify wisdom.     
            Just as education is important, the interest in gaining it, regardless of the circumstances, is equally significant, therefore the value does not rely on where one gains the knowledge, but what he/she learns. Even though inmates are attending classes and taking exams in prison, their education are not less worthy than the knowledge of those who study outside, although it might be limited. Maher (2011) describes the response of having a prominent writer to visit her students in prison as the following:
The James McBride visit is truly wonderful. He tells me on our way out of the prison that my students asked better questions than any he’s been asked on college campuses. He talks in particular about the thoughtful discussion started by one of the students who asked if his book would have been such a success if his mother had been a black woman. I tell him that almost 80% of the women at Bedford are African American and are from some of the worst neighborhoods – and have attended some of the worst schools – in New York City (p. 6).
From the response, it shows that although learning in prison, Maher’s students could think critically and outside the box by asking thoughtful questions to the visitors. The statement portrays the importance of what they learn instead of where they gain the knowledge.
            Education is a significant value one could possess in life. With education, a person would have a wise thought that lead to maturity and a better life and/or future. However, where one attains the knowledge does not important, because the real value of education lays in what he/she learns. For me, to have a dream to continue my study to the highest level, and had the opportunity to make it comes true is truly a privilege, and I believe everyone, no matter who and where they are, have the right to have the same dream, because education is an essential in life. Furthermore, with education and wisdom, the world would be a better place.      
                         

Reference
Maher, J. (2011). Raw Material. The Hudson Review. 

Journal Entry 6

Reflection on Jane Maher’s Raw Material

           Jane Maher’s article, Raw Material, is really an eye-opener to the life of inmates in prison. Through her article, Maher emphasizes the importance of education for everyone, even those who had a harsh and difficult past. Furthermore, Maher really depicts what learning truly is by describing her experience of teaching the women inmates, and in turn, she herself had also learned about life through her students and their past. The article covers many issues regarding learning, education, literacy and determination, and by vividly narrating significant events of her experience, Maher generates the readers to empathize with the inmates and the prison officers. Through the article, it shows that learning could be a two way process, because sometimes by teaching, the teacher too gain meaningful lesson from the students.
            By the end of her article, Maher states how she gets to understand life better by looking at her students’ past and perspective. Their painful history and the gruesome crime they had committed made them tough and harsh, but it also made them vulnerable to the outside world which they did not have the privilege to participate. By teaching and determine to make the inmates’ life better, Maher gained compassion and insightful perspective on life, and that was what her students had taught her. This compelling writing piece is full of precision narratives and important issues, and that makes this article a significant literacy. Besides attracting readers, an article should carry a meaningful content, and that is what Raw Material is all about.   
                                        

Annotated Bibliography

Mental Institution or Prison: 
The Better Place for Mentally Ill Offenders

James, D. J. & Glaze, L. E. (2006). Mental Health Problems of Prison and Jail Inmates. Bureau 
of Justice Statistics Special Report. Retrieved from U.S. Department of Justice:
http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/mhppji.pdf  
This report from the U.S. Department of Justice talks about inmates with mental health problem in prison. According to the report, at midyear 2005, more than half of all prison and jail inmates had a mental health problem, and this includes inmates in State prisons, Federal prisons, and local jails. The report inserts statistical findings of inmates with mental health problem based on gender, symptoms of mental disorders, and history of past mental health issue. The findings of this report are based on data collected from Survey of Inmates in State and Federal Correctional Facilities, and Survey of Inmates in Local Jail. Additionally, the source also reports on inmates with substance use issue such as drug.       
This government report is a reliable source that is useful and significant to the research. The report specifically talks about inmates with mental health problem and how crucial the problem is as it could affect the prison system. The statistics given in the source are strong and will support the thesis of the research, and it also could be used as a proof. However, the report generally talks about inmates with mental health problem, and not mentally ill offenders who were sentenced to prison, therefore the inmates might have become mentally ill while being prisoned, not before they were incarcerated. This issue could limit the use of this source for the research.  
Moran, M. (2014). Jail More Likely Than Hospital for Severely Mentally Ill. Psychiatric News,
            In this source, the author talks about the pressing matter of having more mentally ill inmates in prison than a mental health institution. According to a research by Treatment Advocacy Center, a nonprofit organization dedicated to eliminating barriers to the treatment of severe mental illnesses, 16 percent of people in jails and prisons have a serious mental illness. From this finding, the author raised an important fact which is, the likelihood that a severely mentally ill individual in a particular state is incarcerated rather than hospitalized. Additionally, the article also talks about several recommendations for how the state can reverse the situation as this circumstance should be taken seriously for a better prison system.
             This source is important to the research because it relates to the thesis and discusses the same issue. The recommendations given by the author could be used and expanded in my research as they are significant and useful. The detailed discussion of the report from the Treatment Advocacy Center in the article is convenient and important for my research because it will support my argument and prove my thesis. Since the source is from a legit psychiatric news website, and by the American Psychiatric Association, it is believably reliable and a credible source. 
Pelly, S. (2007, July 22). The Death of Timothy Souders. [Television Broadcast]. In Granatstein,
S. (Producer), 60 Minutes. New York, NY: CBS Broadcasting
            This video reveals the true story behind the death of a mentally unsound offender, Timothy Souders, who had died in prison while serving his three to five year sentence for shoplifting. Prior to his death, Souders was chained down on the floor for 17 hours due to his acute behavior before finally collapsed and pronounced dead, and the cause of death was dehydration. From the interview with his mother, Souders was described as difficult, suicidal, and sometimes delusional since he was a teenager due to his anxiety disorders and manic depression. He was also believed to be needed an urgent psychiatric care rather than being sentenced to prison. Besides Souders’s mother, the interviewees in the video are the Prison’s Director and a family member of another inmate who also had died in prison, and they were featured in the video to talk about the pressing matter of mentally ill inmates who had died during imprisonment.  
                 This source is very related and convenient for the purpose of this research because it shows the treatment given to the mentally ill inmates, which was not helpful to their mental condition. The real footage from the surveillance camera in the prison makes this video really reliable, since the issue discussed was not just based on a theory and conversation, but a real proof. Timothy Souders and the content from the video would be used as a case study in the research. He and his story could demonstrate how important it is for mentally unsound offenders to get psychological treatment rather than be incarcerated. As a source, this video is very significant to my research and thesis.
Samenow, S. E. (2004). Inside the Criminal Mind (2nd Ed.). New York, NY: Crown Publisher
This book by Stanton E. Samenow, a Clinical Psychologist, discusses in detail on the criminal’s profile, behavior and thinking. Samenow covers most aspects of criminal minds that related to various crimes such as rapping, killing, and terrorism. In one of the chapters, he examines psychological disorders that might relate to criminal offenses, and how it affects the thinking process of an offender that will lead him/her to committing crime with or without repentance. Moreover, Samenow describes the life in prison and the effects of incarceration in one of the chapters. The book also talks about the possibility to change a criminal with rehabilitation process, and whether they will most probably get habilitated or will resort to commit more crime.
This source is important because it explores the psychological part of a crime and it could be related to the criminal’s mental disorders. By examining the criminal mind, an argument could be formed on whether they are able to fit in prison life or if it is important for them to get psychological treatment to get fully rehabilitated. As a prominent clinical psychologist and an expert witness specializing in criminal behavior, with thirty four years of experience, Stanton E. Samenow’s credibility is irrefutable; therefore, his book is strongly reliable. One limitation of using this book as a source is this book might be too broad to support the thesis as it covers all aspects of criminal minds and it does not really focus on psychological disorders of a criminal. Nevertheless, Samenow’s insight, thorough examination, knowledge and experience in the book are much needed and useful for this research.       

Research Proposal

Mental Institution vs. Prison:
The Better Place for Inmates with Mental Disorders

          “Not guilty by reason of insanity” is not an uncommon verdict in a trial, although it was used rather more frequently in television and movies than in real life. In actual trials, the verdict is exceedingly rare, hence many mentally unsound offenders end up in prison instead of mental health facility, where they were truly belong. This situation is a call for concern, because it causes congestion of inmates with psychological problems in prisons, and it will affect the rehabilitation process of inmates in the prison institution. According to a report in 2006 by the U.S. Department of Justice, more than half of all prison and jail inmates had a mental health problem, however, they were not treated with a proper clinical treatment. Offenders who were proved to have psychological disorders should be placed in a mental health care facility instead of a prison, because they will get a better chance to recover, hence the less possibility to get back to crime.  
The topic has created a huge debate in the field of law and psychology. Some argue that as offenders committed crimes, they should be treated like other criminals, and receive punishment fairly, which is incarceration. The counter arguments here are: one, as the offenders suffer from psychological disorder, they need to be treated first to understand the purpose of imprisonment; two, as a citizen, they have the right to get treatment for the illness they are suffering from, whether it is psychological or physiological; three, their condition will affect other inmates in prison, and could create undesirable circumstances such as prison homicide and/or suicide. These counter arguments are basically the main features of this research; to look into the reasons why criminal with mental disorders should be treated in a mental health facility. This topic is important in the field of Forensic Psychology, and should be investigated and analyzed, because it could create a better understanding of the prison’s environment and the process of rehabilitation of an offender.  
This research paper will basically base on previous researches, findings, and case studies. The information will be collected from newspaper articles, journals, books, and documentaries. The data collected will be analyzed, and the main features will be emphasized from the information. Some infamous criminals will be used as case studies, and their mental state prior to the time of incarceration will be determined based on psychological diagnosis, then the effects of imprisonment will be studied and discerned. Additionally, opinion from prominent people in the field will be used to back up the claim made, and this opinion will be collected from printed books and articles.
The research paper will begin with an introduction of the topic, where the argument and main claim or thesis will be stated. Then the body of the paper will talk about the advantages of having mentally disorders inmates to be placed in a mental hospital instead of a prison. Case studies of previous infamous offenders will be discussed and analyzed. Moreover, the limitations and cons of emphasizing psychological treatment will be included such as faking disorders to avoid penalty. Opinions and findings from prominent psychologist and criminologist will be cited to support the argument. Finally, the conclusion will be made.





Bibliography
Byron, R. (2014). Criminals Need Mental Health Care. Scientific American. Retrieved from  
James, D. J. & Glaze, L. E. (2006). Mental Health Problems of Prison and Jail Inmates. Bureau  
of Justice Statistics Special Report. Retrieved from
http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/mhppji.pdf   
Moran, M. (2014). Jail More Likely Than Hospital for Severely Mentally Ill. Psychiatric News.
Samenow, S. E. (2004). Inside the Criminal Mind (2nd Ed.). New York, NY: Crown Publisher