Mental Institution or Prison:
The Better Place for Mentally Ill
Offenders
Not every offender with mental illness
ended up in mental institute. Most of the offenders were sentenced to prison
and had to live with other inmates even though their mental stability is not in
a good stage. The questions to draw from this research are, whether sentencing
offenders with mental disorders to live in prison is correct and wise? ; Which
better fit offender with mental illness, prison or mental institution? The
hypothesis or tentative thesis statement is, offenders who were proved to have
psychological disorders should be placed in a mental health care facility
instead of a prison, because they will get a better chance to recover and
transform or rehabilitate as their mental condition would not make them
suitable for incarceration without professional help and/or supervision.
The justice and prison system should
worry about current prison situation where most prisons were congested with
inmates with mental disorders. According to Bureau of Justice statistics
report, more than half of all prison and jail inmates had a mental health
problem in State, federal and local jails (James & Glaze, 2006, p. 1). With
this finding, it shows that probably most offenders with mental health issue
were sentenced to prison, therefore make the prison crowded, and this
circumstances should be taking seriously and be concerned with.
Inmates with mental illness would not
fit in prison, as they need professional help and supervision, and it will
endanger their life to live in prison. One of the examples is Timothy Souders
and his death in prison due to the harsh treatment he received in prison for
his aggressive behavior resulted from mental disorders. Souders was sentenced to prison for
shoplifting, and had died in prison while serving his three to five year. Prior
to his death, Souders was chained down on the floor for 17 hours due to his
acute behavior before finally collapsed and pronounced dead, and the cause of
death was dehydration. Since adolescence, Souders was described as difficult, suicidal,
and sometimes delusional due to his anxiety disorders and manic depression. He
was also believed to be needed an urgent psychiatric care rather than being
sentenced to prison (Pelly, 2007). This case study clearly depicts the
importance of an offender with mental disorders to be institutionalized in
mental health facility rather than prison, because it may endanger his/her life
and it will bring a bad reputation to the justice and prison system.
The concerned situation could be
reversed and corrected. According to Mark Moran (2004), The Treatment Advocacy
Center offers several recommendations for how states can reverse the situation,
and they are:
Assisted
outpatient treatment that requires selected seriously mentally ill people to
take medication under court order as a condition for living in the community; mental
health courts that give offenders a choice between agreeing and adhering to a treatment
plan or going to jail; unannounced state surveys by the Department of Justice
or Institute of Medicine in each state, [it could] enumerate the number of
seriously mentally ill people in jails and prisons and tie federal mental
health block grant funding to the results by state; repeal of the Medicaid Institute
for Mental Diseases (IMD) Exclusion, [it] would provide for greater federal
funding of treatment in the community, the IMD exclusion prohibits federal
Medicaid matching funds from going to inpatient facilities with more than 16
beds whose patient roster is more than 51 percent people with severe mental
illness; reforming treatment laws could make mental health treatment in the
community based on need rather than dangerousness (para. 14).
The
suggestions are important, and should be taken into consideration by the
justice system because they are relevant and significant. The suggestions also
would make a better condition for offenders with mental illness.
Mental institution for offenders
with mental disorders might reduce recidivism than those who were imprisoned.
Robert Byron (2014) in his report states that “Given the mental state of [the] former
inmates—people who were not found insane during their trials—patients found not
guilty by reason of insanity might seem to be especially disordered, and so
they can be. Yet after their release, having been confined in mental hospitals,
not prisons, not only are they less likely to reoffend than disordered inmates,
but they are even less recidivist than offenders without a recognized mental
illness.” (para. 11). From this statement by Byron, who had studied the
recidivism rates for offenders with mental health issue, it proves that letting
criminals to get mental help they need is beneficial as it might rehabilitate
them better than prison, and that should be the purpose of punishment, to
transform an offender to be a better person.
References
Byron,
R. (2014). Criminals Need Mental Health Care. Scientific American Mind, 25 (2).
James,
D. J. & Glaze, L. E. (2006). Mental Health Problems of Prison and Jail
Inmates. Bureau
of
Justice Statistics Special Report. Retrieved from U.S.
Department of Justice:
http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/mhppji.pdf
Moran,
M. (2014). Jail More Likely Than Hospital for Severely Mentally Ill. Psychiatric News,
45
(11). Retrieved from http://psychnews.psychiatryonline.org/doi/full/10.1176/pn.45.11.psychnews_45_11_001
Pelly,
S. (2007, July 22). The Death of Timothy Souders. [Television Broadcast]. In
Granatstein,
S. (Producer), 60 Minutes. New York, NY: CBS Broadcasting
No comments:
Post a Comment