Friday, May 1, 2015

Literary Analysis

A Letter by Martin Luther King, Jr.:
An Important Rhetorical Response in American History

          Writing is a powerful tool that could bring words into certain achievement that sometimes even speech fail to attain. An open letter written in April 1963 by a prominent minister and a social activist, Martin Luther King, Jr., titled Letter from Birmingham Jail (Fagan, 2013, p.17) is one of the examples how powerful writing could be, and how it is able to attain such achievement and importance by expressing ideas and thoughts rhetorically. King wrote the letter during his time in prison, when he was arrested in Birmingham with other activists for conducting a peaceful march and sits-in. The protests conducted by King were a sign against racism and racial segregation in Birmingham. In 1963, Birmingham, Alabama, was described as America’s worst city for racism with racial segregation at its peak, and the issue had become more serious as a church was bombed and it killed four school girls. Therefore, the city of Birmingham became the focus for the civil rights movement (Trueman, 2014). Moreover, King wrote the letter to defend his nonviolent approach in attaining freedom for the African-American community who was oppressed by the tyrant. Letter from Birmingham Jail was also written as a response to a public statement of concern issued by eight white religious leaders of the South (Fagan, 2013, p. 17). It was widely published and became one of the important texts in American history and Civil Rights Movements. The letter is a rhetorical address full of wisdom, and it reveals numerous struggles that the African-American community had been facing on its path to justice.
            King begins his letter by explaining the reason of his being in Birmingham. He believes it is his obligation to fight for justice whenever needed, regardless of the city or state, and if he being accused as an intruder. Prior to his arrival in Birmingham and his arrest, King was described by the religious leaders as “outsiders coming in” (King, 1963, p.1). In response to this comment, King (1963) explains that he is the president of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, an active organization that runs in every Southern state, and the organization has eighty five affiliated organization. One of the affiliates which located in Birmingham invited him to be part of a nonviolent direct-action program and he agreed to join because he believed the program was necessary by looking at the situation in Birmingham (King, 1963, p.1). King reaffirms his invitation through the letter and argues that he was invited instead of intruded, and by doing so he states his right to join the program and justifies his present in Birmingham. Additionally, King also stresses that he is in Birmingham because injustice presents there, and it is his obligation to be concerned wherever injustice emerged.
Another reason for King being in Birmingham was his strong conscience of justice and love. Mary King (1999) in her book titled Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King, Jr., The power of nonviolent action, states that “In King’s perspective, Love was inseparable from justice, and in favoring the Greek word agape he meant to emphasize Love in its sense of goodwill towards humanity. Such love asks nothing in return.” (p. 260). As a pious Christian, a religion of the love of God and reciprocal love (King, 1999, p. 260), King is a man who strongly believes in love, hence made him a person of just, and he will fight for justice whenever needed. His conscience of justice could be seen in his own words in the letter that says “I am in Birmingham because injustice is here” (King, 1963, p.1). King further expresses (1963) that he believes he is related to all communities and states, therefore he should not be considered as an outsider, and thus he has the responsibility to face any oppression, especially when it is related to racism because it is a disruption to justice (p.1). King’s belief on his duty to protect justice is a reflection of his strong belief in love and righteousness.          
Through the letter, King depicts his integrity of a man with high wisdom by explicitly stating his stance on approaching oppression by nonviolence resistance. Being a preacher and an educated activist, his ideology on this approach is very much needed and impressive. Naturally, one would fight violently to attain something after being repressed and oppressed for long, but King has a distinct idea. According to Greg Moses (1997) in Revolution of Conscience: Martin Luther King, Jr, and the Philosophy of Nonviolence, King insists that nonviolence protest is a psychological militancy, because it is an excellent means of gathering massive anger and frustration, then releasing it with discipline but with maximum effect. Furthermore, nonviolence action offers the most intelligent means of confronting social disorder without instigating riots (Moses, 1997, p. 155-156). King’s argument of nonviolent fight indicates his personality of a wise person, who speaks with such knowledge and insight, for this argument is relevant and legit.  
Additionally, King views nonviolence as a mean to educate people to bring them towards a better state and understanding. According to King (1963), “We must see the need of having nonviolent gadflies to create the kind of tension in society that will help men to rise from the dark depths of prejudice and racism to the majestic heights of understanding and brotherhood” (p. 2). Moreover, King believes violence would not bring desire consequences, and people need tolerance to form a unity and consensus. King (1967) claims, “The problem with hatred and violence is that they intensify the fears of the white majority, and leave them less ashamed of their prejudices toward Negroes” (cited from Moses, 1997, p. 163). This statement describes the consequences of fighting for justice with violence, where it could bring more oppression rather than empathy. This point affirmed by King once again portrays his wisdom in confronting the issue of racism, and King’s ideology was proved to be wised as the approach was evidently succeeded a few years after the Letter from Birmingham was composed.
Nonviolence approach insisted by King had resulted in one of the most important part in American and Civil Right Movement history. As the eyewitnesses, LaFayette, Johnson and Lewis (2013) vividly describe the history of marching accomplished by King and his followers from Selma to Montgomery in 1965 as a mean of protest against voting right restriction towards the African-American community. On March 21, 1965, King, his followers, and the people in Selma, Alabama, walked from Selma to Montgomery for five days in a peaceful march with a permission from the Federal District Court. The action was taken as a protest against the restriction on voting for the African-Americans. Nonviolence creates pressure to the rulers and it evidently worked, for through the march, President Johnson was pressured to pass the bill to eliminate the restriction on voting for the African Americans, and finally in August 1965, Voting Rights Act 1965 was signed (LaFayette, Johnson & Lewis, 2013, p. 131-142). From this event, it shows that nonviolent approaches might be time consuming and have to be emphasized more than violent approach, but it is worth the achievement which gained through diplomatic and understanding; thus proves King’s ideology on the nonviolent fight as wise and legit.
In his letter, King also discusses a few aspects of struggle in attaining freedom and justice, which made the letter an influential reference to Civil Right Movement and American history. King specifically talks about law and the justice system, White people’s silence, Church and religious leaders, and police and their treatment towards the African-Americans; and how these aspects prevent justice to be achieved by the community. King firmly states his opinion on segregation as an unjust law. According to King (1963), “Any law that uplifts human personality is just. Any law that degrades human personality is unjust.” This powerful statement clearly depicts that segregation, as it lead to inferiority to the segregated, is not correct and unjust. This rule, which was considered a law in the era, segregated colored people with the Whites in public places such as restaurants, shops, hotels and public transports. Even after the law banned segregation of race, some states still disregard it and continue to deploy the act.
Talking about the Whites, King believes that not all people in white community hate the Black people and accept the injustice actions towards them, but sadly, their support were half-hearted and moderate. They constantly says “I agree with you in the goal you seek, but can’t agree with your methods of direct action.’ (King, 1963, p.3). To King, this is frustrating because he rather get an outright rejection, than receive a lukewarm acceptance. The ignorance of the Whites proves that they prefer a situation that has no tension than justice.
The religious leaders and the church also has not contributed to the process of attaining justice for the Black community. According to King (1963), the church and its leadership does not support the freedom movement and preach on desegregation decision because of the law, instead of saying that integration is morally right and everyone is the same (p. 5). By not supporting the right cause, the religious leaders in a way preventing the freedom to be attained and it is not supposed to happen because every religion teach kindness and righteousness without prejudice and discrimination.
Lastly, King points the treatment by the police towards the African-Americans. According to King, police treats Black people with disrespect and inhuman. Even in the jail, Blacks are treated degradingly. King (1963) states, “If you would watch them push and curse old Negro women and young Negro girls; if you would see them slap and kick old Negro men and young boys…” (p. 5). This ugly treatment shows the police’s perception towards the African Americans. They disrespect them and even treated them with no humanity. With this attitude, King believes it is harder for him and the people to gain freedom and justice against racism and prejudice, therefore their struggle continues and get more difficult every time.         
Martin Luther King, Jr is a remarkable activist and a prominent leader. His ideology on nonviolent fights against racism, racial segregation and oppression is courageous and distinctive, although he was accused of being a disturber and an intruder. This approach should be used as an example in any fights against injustice because diplomatic and understanding are much needed and last longer than violence, although it might take some times to achieve. Letter from Birmingham Jail written by King stresses the need to gain freedom and the aspects of struggles of attaining the freedom. The letter is an influential text to Civil Rights Movements and it continues to be a great significance to the history as the content carries such value to the nation. 


Martin Luther King, Jr.











Read the full letter here:
Letter From Birmingham Jail





References
King, M. L. (1963). Letter from Birmingham Jail. The Atlantic Monthly. The Negro is Your
Brother, Vol. 212 (2), 78-88.
Fagan, D. (2013). LETTER FROM BIRMINGHAM JAIL. AppleSeeds, Vol.16 (2), 17-19.
King, M. (1999). Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King, Jr, The power of nonviolent action.
Paris, France: UNESCO
LaFayette, B., Johnson, K. L., & Lewis, J. R. (2013). In Peace and Freedom: My Journey in
Selma. Lexington, KY: University Press of Kentucky.   
Moses, G. (1997). Revolution of Conscience: Martin Luther King, Jr., and the Philosophy of
Nonviolence. New York, NY: The Guilford Press
Trueman, C. (2014). Birmingham 1963. History Learning Site. Retrieved from
           

No comments:

Post a Comment