Mental Institution vs. Prison:
The Better Place for Inmates with
Mental Disorders
“Not guilty by reason of insanity” is not an uncommon verdict in a trial, although it was used rather more frequently in television and movies than in real life. In actual trials, the verdict is exceedingly rare, hence many mentally unsound offenders end up in prison instead of mental health facility, where they were truly belong. This situation is a call for concern, because it causes congestion of inmates with psychological problems in prisons, and it will affect the rehabilitation process of inmates in the prison institution. According to a report in 2006 by the U.S. Department of Justice, more than half of all prison and jail inmates had a mental health problem, however, they were not treated with a proper clinical treatment. Offenders who were proved to have psychological disorders should be placed in a mental health care facility instead of a prison, because they will get a better chance to recover, hence the less possibility to get back to crime.
The topic has created a huge debate in
the field of law and psychology. Some argue that as offenders committed crimes,
they should be treated like other criminals, and receive punishment fairly,
which is incarceration. The counter arguments here are: one, as the offenders
suffer from psychological disorder, they need to be treated first to understand
the purpose of imprisonment; two, as a citizen, they have the right to get
treatment for the illness they are suffering from, whether it is psychological
or physiological; three, their condition will affect other inmates in prison,
and could create undesirable circumstances such as prison homicide and/or
suicide. These counter arguments are basically the main features of this
research; to look into the reasons why criminal with mental disorders should be
treated in a mental health facility. This topic is important in the field of
Forensic Psychology, and should be investigated and analyzed, because it could
create a better understanding of the prison’s environment and the process of
rehabilitation of an offender.
This research paper will basically base
on previous researches, findings, and case studies. The information will be
collected from newspaper articles, journals, books, and documentaries. The data
collected will be analyzed, and the main features will be emphasized from the
information. Some infamous criminals will be used as case studies, and their
mental state prior to the time of incarceration will be determined based on
psychological diagnosis, then the effects of imprisonment will be studied and
discerned. Additionally, opinion from prominent people in the field will be
used to back up the claim made, and this opinion will be collected from printed
books and articles.
The research paper will begin with an
introduction of the topic, where the argument and main claim or thesis will be
stated. Then the body of the paper will talk about the advantages of having
mentally disorders inmates to be placed in a mental hospital instead of a
prison. Case studies of previous infamous offenders will be discussed and
analyzed. Moreover, the limitations and cons of emphasizing psychological
treatment will be included such as faking disorders to avoid penalty. Opinions
and findings from prominent psychologist and criminologist will be cited to
support the argument. Finally, the conclusion will be made.
Bibliography
Byron,
R. (2014). Criminals Need Mental Health Care. Scientific American. Retrieved from
James,
D. J. & Glaze, L. E. (2006). Mental Health Problems of Prison and Jail
Inmates. Bureau
of
Justice Statistics Special Report. Retrieved from
http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/mhppji.pdf
Moran,
M. (2014). Jail More Likely Than Hospital for Severely Mentally Ill. Psychiatric News.
Samenow,
S. E. (2004). Inside the Criminal Mind
(2nd Ed.). New York, NY: Crown Publisher
No comments:
Post a Comment