Thursday, May 7, 2015

Journal Entry 7

Reflection on The Birthmark

The Birthmark, by Nathaniel Hawthorne is a moving fiction which explores the meaning of true love, obsession and perfection. The story revolves around two main characters, Aylmer and Georgiana. Aylmer is a scientist who marries Georgiana, a beautiful woman with a birthmark on her cheek. After they were married, Aylmer could not look pass the birthmark which he found hideous and distracting, although he did not seem to mind the mark before they were married. He loves Georgiana, but the obsession to erase the birthmark on her cheek seems to get stronger than the love he has for her, and as Georgiana loves her husband so much, she agreed to let him removes the mark. After Aylmer removed the mark, Georgiana becomes weaker day by day, and at the end, she died. Through the story, it shows that one should love another unconditionally, and accept the other person’s imperfection thoroughly, because no one is perfect in this life.
Love is a pure emotion that should come with sincerity and devotion. In the story, Aylmer fails to fulfill the love he has for his wife by being obsess with science, and tries to make her perfect according to his opinion on beauty. The mark on her check should make Georgiana more beautiful in Aylmer’s eyes as he has supposedly be in love with her and accept her sincerely, but his repulsion and obsession suggests that he might not love his wife with all his heart. With his narcissistic personality, perhaps Aylmer married Georgiana to prove that he is the best, and could win her over other men who were waiting to ask her hand in marriage, and to prove himself further, he resorts to make her perfect after they were married. If Aylmer did marry his wife to prove himself, then Aylmer was never truly in love with Georgiana, because if he had, he would always be able to look beyond her imperfection, especially when it is something that is related to look. As a human, imperfection is actually an essential to be a perfect person, therefore one should love the other person’s flaw, because it is part of him/her that makes him/her a whole person. To quote a notable author and philosopher, Sam Keen (1997), on love and acceptance, “We come to love not by finding a perfect person, but by learning to see an imperfect person perfectly” (Cited from BrainyQuote, 2015). Through the wise quote, it depicts how important it is to accept a person with his/her imperfection, and as love grows, one should tend to learn the imperfection thoroughly and accept it, because love is acceptance and tolerance.



Read the tale here: 
The Birthmark



Reference
BrainyQuote. (2015). Sam Keen Quotes. BrainyQuote. Retrieved from
http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/s/samkeen171241.html


No comments:

Post a Comment