Mental Institution or Prison:
The Better Place for Mentally Ill Offenders
The Better Place for Mentally Ill Offenders
James, D. J. & Glaze, L. E. (2006). Mental Health Problems of Prison and Jail Inmates. Bureau
of
Justice Statistics Special Report. Retrieved from U.S.
Department of Justice:
http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/mhppji.pdf
This
report from the U.S. Department of Justice talks about inmates with mental
health problem in prison. According to the report, at midyear 2005, more than
half of all prison and jail inmates had a mental health problem, and this
includes inmates in State prisons, Federal prisons, and local jails. The report
inserts statistical findings of inmates with mental health problem based on
gender, symptoms of mental disorders, and history of past mental health issue. The
findings of this report are based on data collected from Survey of Inmates in
State and Federal Correctional Facilities, and Survey of Inmates in Local Jail.
Additionally, the source also reports on inmates with substance use issue such
as drug.
This
government report is a reliable source that is useful and significant to the research.
The report specifically talks about inmates with mental health problem and how
crucial the problem is as it could affect the prison system. The statistics
given in the source are strong and will support the thesis of the research, and
it also could be used as a proof. However, the report generally talks about
inmates with mental health problem, and not mentally ill offenders who were
sentenced to prison, therefore the inmates might have become mentally ill while
being prisoned, not before they were incarcerated. This issue could limit the
use of this source for the research.
Moran,
M. (2014). Jail More Likely Than Hospital for Severely Mentally Ill. Psychiatric News,
45
(11). Retrieved from http://psychnews.psychiatryonline.org/doi/full/10.1176/pn.45.11.psychnews_45_11_001
In
this source, the author talks about the pressing matter of having more mentally
ill inmates in prison than a mental health institution. According to a research
by Treatment Advocacy Center, a nonprofit organization dedicated to eliminating
barriers to the treatment of severe mental illnesses, 16 percent of people in
jails and prisons have a serious mental illness. From this finding, the author
raised an important fact which is, the likelihood that a severely mentally ill
individual in a particular state is incarcerated rather than hospitalized. Additionally,
the article also talks about several recommendations for how the state can
reverse the situation as this circumstance should be taken seriously for a
better prison system.
This source is important to the research
because it relates to the thesis and discusses the same issue. The
recommendations given by the author could be used and expanded in my research
as they are significant and useful. The detailed discussion of the report from
the Treatment Advocacy Center in the article is convenient and important for my
research because it will support my argument and prove my thesis. Since the
source is from a legit psychiatric news website, and by the American
Psychiatric Association, it is believably reliable and a credible source.
Pelly,
S. (2007, July 22). The Death of Timothy Souders. [Television Broadcast]. In
Granatstein,
S. (Producer), 60 Minutes. New York, NY: CBS Broadcasting
This video reveals the true story
behind the death of a mentally unsound offender, Timothy Souders, who had died
in prison while serving his three to five year sentence for shoplifting. Prior
to his death, Souders was chained down on the floor for 17 hours due to his
acute behavior before finally collapsed and pronounced dead, and the cause of
death was dehydration. From the interview with his mother, Souders was
described as difficult, suicidal, and sometimes delusional since he was a
teenager due to his anxiety disorders and manic depression. He was also
believed to be needed an urgent psychiatric care rather than being sentenced to
prison. Besides Souders’s mother, the interviewees in the video are the Prison’s
Director and a family member of another inmate who also had died in prison, and
they were featured in the video to talk about the pressing matter of mentally
ill inmates who had died during imprisonment.
This
source is very related and convenient for the purpose of this research because
it shows the treatment given to the mentally ill inmates, which was not helpful
to their mental condition. The real footage from the surveillance camera in the
prison makes this video really reliable, since the issue discussed was not just
based on a theory and conversation, but a real proof. Timothy Souders and the
content from the video would be used as a case study in the research. He and
his story could demonstrate how important it is for mentally unsound offenders
to get psychological treatment rather than be incarcerated. As a source, this
video is very significant to my research and thesis.
Samenow,
S. E. (2004). Inside the Criminal Mind
(2nd Ed.). New York, NY: Crown Publisher
This
book by Stanton E. Samenow, a Clinical Psychologist, discusses in detail on the
criminal’s profile, behavior and thinking. Samenow covers most aspects of
criminal minds that related to various crimes such as rapping, killing, and
terrorism. In one of the chapters, he examines psychological disorders that
might relate to criminal offenses, and how it affects the thinking process of
an offender that will lead him/her to committing crime with or without
repentance. Moreover, Samenow describes the life in prison and the effects of
incarceration in one of the chapters. The book also talks about the possibility
to change a criminal with rehabilitation process, and whether they will most
probably get habilitated or will resort to commit more crime.
This
source is important because it explores the psychological part of a crime and
it could be related to the criminal’s mental disorders. By examining the
criminal mind, an argument could be formed on whether they are able to fit in
prison life or if it is important for them to get psychological treatment to
get fully rehabilitated. As a prominent clinical psychologist and an expert
witness specializing in criminal behavior, with thirty four years of
experience, Stanton E. Samenow’s credibility is irrefutable; therefore, his
book is strongly reliable. One limitation of using this book as a source is this
book might be too broad to support the thesis as it covers all aspects of
criminal minds and it does not really focus on psychological disorders of a
criminal. Nevertheless, Samenow’s insight, thorough examination, knowledge and
experience in the book are much needed and useful for this research.
No comments:
Post a Comment